Efohvee

Only Two Games Have Ever Scored a 99

You probably think a 99 on Metacritic means the same thing every time. It has happened twice, and the two numbers barely measure the same thing.

So what does GTA VI's 99 tell you? And what did Ocarina of Time's tell you in 1998?

Ocarina of Time has sat alone at 99 for 28 years. That score comes from 22 critic reviews, and every one of them was positive.

GTA VI came out today with its own 99. As of this morning Metacritic counts 150 reviews behind it. Every one of those was positive too.

Twenty-two people agreeing is a strong opinion. A hundred and fifty agreeing is closer to a weather report.

I think the new one was harder to get. More critics means more chances for someone to hate the driving or the 30 frames per second. Nobody did.

I also think the old one has had more time to be wrong. Ocarina's 99 has survived 28 years of people going back to it. GTA VI's has survived one morning.

Which 99 would you trust more, the small one that aged or the big one that just showed up? I'll be over here watching the review count tick up.

Games in this article

Keep shelves of what you play. Free on iPhone and Android.

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play